Thanks for the feedback! Just out of curiosity, what version of Clearspace are you using? It sounds like your tag groups are still in a drop down list, which I believe was the pre 1.1 UI. We got a lot of similar feedback, so for 1.1 we pulled them out of a drop down, gave them their own icon, and highlight them if they are selected. If you are using a newer version of Clearspace and you still find the tag group UI to be inadequate, please elaborate on that so we can improve it ![]()
Thanks!
I'm on 1.2. I acknowledge that once you confirmed that it has its own icon, that I did look closer, a lot closer, and can make out that it is a folder with a pink ticket inside. I can also just make out the highlighting, but it is very pale on my monitor. I suppose you could say that this is just a usability issue, however I would still assert that more could be done to promote their prominence and use.
I'll create a separate feature enhancement request on the matter.
Sounds good. Thank you very much for the feedback!
Do tag groups have RSS feeds? (They might; I actually don't know.) Can you get email notification from them? Can you search for content within specific tag groups? Can I get the top members for a tag group? Can you associate a blog with a specific tag group? Can I designate a separate set of admins for a tag group?
There seem to have a lot of reasons to use a community/space instead of a tag group.
Good points John.
However, I'd that this ups the game in regard to giving more prominace, features,and use of Tag Groups.
The prime motivation for using a space should be for access control reasons.
Based on the response I received in Email notification by tag group, this is supposedly a possibility for 2.1. I agree, it is a must because without it spaces are generally preferred based on usability, even when tag groups are really the better route.
One technique that is often used is for improved tag navigation is to give a tag a parent type (e.g. Event, People, Place, Topic, Language). I've been looking at tag groups to add a parent category to tags. Here is an example of tags visualization that leverage parent type to create groups of tags that make it easier on the brain to navigate a site http://www.mefeedia.com/tags.htm.
The main problem is that using tag groups is that you can't represent hierarchy (greater than 2). Ideally I'd like to use tags groups for simple taxonomy. Let's say i want to group content that in a way that matches a website layout w/out reverting to sub-spaces.
For example MediaWiki provides a nice way to add specialized Category tags to content and allows you to navigate via Categories w/out needing to create a space hierarchy so you can convince people to just create high level documents in one space.
For this news article:
http://en.wikinews.org/wiki/US_Midwest_floods_raise_concerns_about_water_quality
Which is categorized this way:
/North America/United States/Iowa/Disasters and accidents/Weather/Health
If I do need to represent a space that is more than 2 layers deep my only options seems to sub-spaces.
I agree totally with this more flexible approach - hierarchical files structures are too restrictive. Clearspace is definitely going in the right direction here but the functional support needs to be stronger.
Firstly, the selection and confirmation of Tag Groups needs to be more evident. Currently, when content has been 'filtered' by a Tag Group - the 'filter used is not highlighted i.e. you only know because you just selected it. I have a memory like a fruit fly ;-).
Tag Groups are also a bit buried, a second class citizen to sub-spaces. It would be useful for them to be selectable and displayable like sub-spaces, but with a separate icon.